|
In the 1960s, corporate decision-making was mostly hierarchical. Leadership made the decisions, employees did what they were told. Knowing that, it makes Toyota’s 1966 policy changes all the more surprising. You see, Toyota leadership decided to let their lowest-level employees make the types of decisions that could cost the company a massive amount of money Specifically, they empowered the assembly line workers to pull the Andon Cord. <cue foreboding sound> The Andon Cord is an emergency stop system. When you pull the cord (or press the button, as the case may be) it immediately shuts down production in the auto plant. Stopping production in an auto plant is a huge friggin deal. To put it in perspective, it costs car manufacturers nearly $40,0001 every minute that production is stopped. That adds up very quickly. Keep in mind that the average auto assembly line worker makes only $40k per year2. That means just 60 seconds of stoppage will cost the company more than the entire salary of the very worker who initiated the stop in the first place. That’s a lot of pressure to put on front-line workers. Imagine if it cost your company an employee’s entire salary every minute they made a glaring mistake and stopped the team’s productivity. You’d probably be watching every single thing those employees were doing. Maybe you’d even be a borderline micromanager. I mean, it would make sense, right? Toyota dared to think differently. In a world of top-down leadership, they decided to believe in the distributed decision-making power of their employees. Their thinking changed the world. We will get to that in a minute, but first, we have to kibitz about Kodak.
How Decision-Making Can Kill A CompanyBack in the late 20th century, Kodak was synonymous with camera film. At their peak, they owned 90% of the film market3. Nobody even came close to competing with them. Kodak was also at the forefront of technological innovation at the time. In fact, in 1975 they were the first company to invent the digital camera. Unfortunately, Kodak’s decision-making structure was far from revolutionary. While businesses in the 1980s were moving towards a more distributed decision-making process, Kodak was stuck in a hierarchical model. Senior leadership made all big decisions, but, like most senior leaders, they didn’t have their ears to the ground. I’m not sure if they had anything to the ground. Kodak’s leadership decided to bury the future of digital cameras in order to maintain its current market share in non-digital film. You know how this story ended. Canon, Sony, and Nikon invested heavily in R&D for digital cameras. Why?
Distributed Decision-MakingInnovation, agility, and growth come from effective decision-making processes. Effective decision-making is not hierarchical. Quite a few studies have shown that every new generation wants to be more empowered with decision-making than the previous one (check out Deloitte’s 2024 Growth Human Capital Trends report) But let’s get back to Toyota and their Andon Cord experiment for a hot minute. It turns out that Toyota’s move to empower front-line workers not only transformed their culture, but it transformed their industry. By empowering the workers, Toyota immediately experienced better quality control and fewer manufacturing errors. More importantly, they created an entire culture focused on constant improvement. Toyota’s “lean manufacturing” process has since become the standard for all car manufacturers. All that from simply empowering employees to make decisions.
How to Distribute DecisionsDo you want your team to be more innovative, agile, and growth-minded? If you answered yes (which happens to be the correct answer), the solution is simple: you need to define the decisions each employee is empowered to make. For most companies, there are only a few areas of decision-making authority. Here are five common categories:
Let’s review each one. 1. Finance-based DecisionsEvery employee should be given a clear understanding of their spending authority. For instance, Ritz-Carlton prioritizes its customers' happiness. To show this, they empower employees to spend up to $2000 to resolve customer issues or improve a guest’s experience4. 2. Strategy, Rules & PrioritiesSometimes employees are confronted with decisions that may challenge the strategic direction or the priorities of their job. Which employees can change the rules on their own? Check out this example. Nordstrom department stores are legendary for accepting returns at any time for any of their products - even if it has already been worn. One time a person tried to return a set of car tires to their local Nordstrom. The customer insisted they bought the tires at Nordstrom. There was only one problem: Nordstrom doesn’t sell tires5. Famously, the Nordstrom employee gave the person a full refund and, in doing so, helped catapult Nordstrom’s brand as a leader in customer happiness. 3. PeoplePeriodically, people may need to have their roles and responsibilities reevaluated or changed. It could be for a variety of different reasons, none of which I’ll get into now. When it happens, who has the authority to make those decisions? It’s important to clarify this. 4. PartnersCompanies have different types of partners. There are SaaS partners, strategic partners, investment partners, sponsors, and many others. What decision-making authority do different employees at different levels have with different types of partners? 5. ProcessFinally, processes are both the daily tactics employed by workers to achieve their goals, as well as the company processes employees follow to conduct business. Who owns these processes? Who can alter the way things are done? Who is empowered to make changes to the problems they see?
Empowering Decision-MakingIn our world where agility, innovation, and adaptability are the building blocks for success, empowering employees to make decisions is essential. By allowing employees to make their own decisions, you build a team that feels valued and inspired. Toyota was one of the first companies to understand that. Now, the fastest-growing companies are the ones that get it. So tell me: How are you teaching your team to make decisions? The question isn’t about how much money it will cost to address the poor decisions, the question is how much it will cost if you don’t let them decide in the first place. Maybe it’s time for you to pull the Andon cord. How good is your company culture? Take the free culture assessment |
If Simon Sinek and John Oliver had a baby, this is it. Every Monday and Thursday 13k+ subscribers get a lump of leadership lessons with a healthy helping of humor. “It’s the only newsletter I read in full every week,” said a lot of people.
25,000 years ago, our early ancestors created a small invention that, as it turns out, would have a monumental impact on the growth and development of modern man. No, it wasn’t the ability to control fire. I know that’s what you were thinking. That invention was about 400,000 years ago. Nice guess, though. You were only 375,000 years off. It wasn’t the invention of the wheel, either. You’d be shocked to learn when that happened (or watch this video). The small invention I am referring to -...
I got injured right as I started training for the New York City Marathon. I’m not surprised.My wife wasn’t surprised.My friends weren’t surprised.Nobody was surprised. It’s the type of thing I do - I injure myself at the most inopportune time in the most ridiculous way. I once tripped on the sidewalk and broke my back in two places. I once slipped off a cliff and hung on for dear life until someone came by with a rope to pull me to safety. But back to the NYC Marathon. It turns out I strained...
294. Perfection Is Not The Purpose My daughter’s elementary school recently underwent a few upgrades. They redesigned the library, created a new lunch area, and updated the playground with some really nifty structures that I wish were in the playgrounds I played in as a kid. It all looks so perfect. Next to the playground, the school built a new walkway that climbs the slow rise to the administration building. Not coincidentally, the walkway has 26 steps, each representing a letter of the...